Welcome to The 3-4, a website dedicated to NFL analysis, predictions and recent events. We wrote 32 extensive team previews and will be writing about all things football throughout the year. We will be scouting players off game tape, evaluating them, predicting NFL and NCAA games, and much more! If you would like us to write about something in particular, let us know!

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Vincent Brown Scouting Report

The following scouting report by;
Guest Contributor and NFL Draft writer, Fernando Stepensky


Vincent Brown, WR, San Diego State, 5’11 187 lbs

SKILLS

Strengths: Vincent Brown is by far the most underrated player in the draft. Whether it is because of his average size (6’0 195 lbs) or because he doesn’t attend a National Championship winning school (SDSU), the receiver just isn’t getting as much attention as he should.

It is no coincidence that he had 69 receptions in his senior year—this guy definitely knows how to get open and catch the ball. Nonetheless, his best attribute is getting the ball. It starts with his burst off the line; once that gunslinger says, “hike” Vincent goes 100% and gets off the line as if it were on fire. Sometimes his excellent bursts catch DBs off guard, which gives him the separation he needs to catch the ball right from the start.

The thing that is so shocking about him is his intelligence in route running. Earlier this year, in a game against TCU, he had a 50 plus yard TD reception. He ran an out and up route to perfection. This is a good sign because double moves are used often in the NFL. Also, usually wide receivers who have mastered the double move are very successful against the leagues top DBs. The quick difference in his speed caught the DB napping and created separation for the senior. He managed to get the diving reception for a touchdown. The one play embodies what Vincent Brown is all about.

The way he creates separation on a regular basis is depicted above with his off the line burst. Brown also changes speeds so quickly and he has this break/juke in the middle of his routes that absolutely baffle opposing cornerbacks; his footwork plays a large role in this.  His footwork helps him get in and out of his cuts quickly and swiftly. Which is common characteristic in good route runners like him.

Sometimes he does alter his route, because he reads the defense so well. His route running intelligence must be emphasized. He just knows where to go and when to go. His instinct gives him a feel of where to go and the majority of the time, his instinct is right. That is also another aspect of his game that deserves praise, his catch in traffic. It is complicated to explain it in its entirety. It is just that his ability to adjust to the ball in traffic is truly impressive. The overlying point is he is tough and he doesn’t care if there is one defender or if there are 11, around him, he will still catch it.

Vincent Brown’s incredible hands and superb footwork combine to create a great sideline receiver. He showed off his great sideline receiving at his pro day (which I attended) and especially in his games like the one against TCU. His specialty route is the slant and the out/in route. When he does a deep out route to the sideline, it is an almost guaranteed catch.


Combining Vincent’s footwork, intelligence, route running, breaks, big reliable hands, and great toughness make him one of the most prolific receivers in the draft. Although, their has never been a prospect without his share of flaws and weaknesses.

Weaknesses: Vincent has very few flaws when it comes to before the catch. Although, after it gets to 0.2 seconds before the catch and after the catch, the flaws begin to show. His running motion is by all means “awkward”. I was at his pro day and was told by a coach and a scout that his running motion is in fact awkward. They told me, “it doesn’t look natural when he is pumping his arms”. This is something that is of concern because it could greatly affect his already weak speed.

He ran a 4.68 at the combine, which is bad for a receiver, and he ran a 4.53 at his pro day, which is average, nothing too impressive.  An NFL free agent that was scheduled to work out at the pro day (didn’t because of the CBA) told me, “It is all his straight line speed, it just isn’t there.” He quite frankly is right and his coaches knew that coming in to his senior year. Very few times did you see him run a pure streak route. Normally he is given a double move route. That gives him time for separation on his excellent breaks and then, sadly, gives the DB time to catch back up once the streak starts. In the game against Utah this year he created separation just like I depicted and once he caught the ball and had 7 yards of separation, the DB started coming up toward him.

Vincent Brown’s run after the catch ability is another concern talent evaluators have to deal with. As I said his straight line speed and his running motion are awkward, but I am talking about his ball carrier vision. Throughout the tapes I have studied on him, I can always see a better opening than the one he decides to take. In the game against Navy this year he was given a screen, there were three defenders on both sides of him and a hole right between them that was quickly closing. I noticed that without having to pause the tape, he noticed it about 10 yards late when the gap was long gone and he was already on the ground. This continues in many of his games. The NFL is becoming very caught up with YAC (yards after catch) and if he doesn’t improve that aspect of his game he will not have much luck in the NFL.

Speaking of important aspects one must perfect at the wide receiver position before going to the NFL, blocking is key.  A trend you are have been exposed to in recent years is multi versatile players. Basically, the more things that you can do, the more likely you are of succeeding. Something that Vincent needs to work on is his blocking. He blocks pretty well for the first half of the play, but once the running back gets close to him he almost always lets his defender get loose and tackle him. I just don’t see the effort there on his blocks. That is definitely something he needs to improve for two reasons. One, to show me he is committed and gives it 100% on every play(counting running plays). Second, it shows the coaches that they can use him every down either as a receiver or an excellent blocker 

ANALYSIS

Best Fit: He would definitely be best suited on a pass first team, at least for the time being.  Due to his poor blocking on run players, he wouldn’t fit very well on a run first team. Although, that doesn’t mean he wouldn’t be drafted for one. The chances are high that he will go to a run first or balanced team and then he will be expected to learn blocking well!

Personally, I can see him potentially going to the Bengals, the Vikings, but the best fit could be the Arizona Cardinals.

Either the Cardinals could trade back in the third or draft him in the fourth. However, he seems to fit the team perfectly. They ran the ball a great deal last year (due to terrible quarterbacks), but this year they should have a clear-cut starter that would fit right in with Vincent Brown.

X-Factor: His X-Factor will be his blocking and his route running. That is ultimately going to make or break him. If he is on a team and he resembles his great route running and starts working on his blocking, he could be a great receiver. Blocking and route running will ultimately make or break Vincent Brown.

Where he will be drafted: Middle fourth to late fifth. People are saying that it could be in the sixth or even later, but I feel teams will realize his potential and draft him somewhere in the fourth or fifth. He will be one of those “risers” come draft day.

Where he should be drafted: He should be drafted right where I put he will be drafted. Fourth or fifth round is perfect for him. People do notice his tremendous upside, but the worry of his speed and blocking demotes him to these later rounds. 

NFL Comparison: Derrick Mason, WR, Baltimore Ravens

Vincent Brown vs. TCU 



Vincent Brown Draft Preview

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Ricky Stanzi Scouting Report

Ricky Stanzi, QB, Iowa, 6'4 223 lbs

SKILLS

Strengths: Ricky Stanzi is a well built quarterback with ideal size for the NFL. With his big frame, Stanzi shows the ability to slide step pressure within the pocket. His ability to move from within the pocket consistently stood out to me. While avoiding sacks, Stanzi also does a good job of keeping his eye level downfield, continuing to follow through with his pass progression. He has a good feel in the pocket and understands when to tuck the ball and run. He will check all options before giving up on a play. 

Stanzi is proficient and technically sound in his pass drops, looking comfortable in each of his 3 step, 5 step, and 7 step drops (albeit 7 step drops at Iowa are hard to come by). Does a good job of setting his base wide enough to avoid over striding, and transfers his weight in a smooth manner. Nice over the top delivery with good arm action and a quick enough release, the ball looks good coming out of his hand. Release point is what you want to see, and never has trouble seeing coverages or getting passes defensed at the line of scrimmage. Has adequate anticipation of coverage's and passing lanes. 

Accuracy in the short to intermediate passing game is excellent. An efficient passer who sticks the football on his receivers' numbers. Consistently puts the ball in a position where his receiver can pick up yards after the catch (YAC). His timing on these routes, similarly to Andy Dalton, is able to recompense for Stanzi's lack of arm strength and velocity. Generally does a strong job on pre-snap reads, adjusting to the defense's coverage and knowing where he wants to go with the football. Picks up most of his completions in short passing situations. 

Stanzi's strong mental makeup and short term memory are his biggest strengths. A student of the game, Stanzi a senior QB, played in a pro-style offense at Iowa dropping back from center a majority of the time. Matt Bowen of the National Football Post said Stanzi, "[I]s widely regarded by league personnel as a dedicated student of the game in the film room." Stnazi devotes nearly 20 hours of each game week studying for his next opponent. Coach Kirk Ferentz says about Stanzi, "Nobody is more committed than him, and I’m saying that with all due respect to a lot of good guys. But he’s right at the top of the list.”

Early in his career at Iowa, Stanzi struggled mightily with interceptions and slow starts. Heading into his senior 2010 season, he had a TD/INT ratio of 31/25; hardly spectacular and evidence of his inconsistent decision making. The positive spin off is that although he started games slowly and struggled with turnovers, Stanzi would never let previous mistakes cloud his confidence. Stanzi is quick to forget his interceptions and immediately readies himself to make the correct pass on the next series. His body language is always motivating and positive, and his teammates seem to feed off of that. 

In his senior season, Stanzi finally put it all together in terms of consistently making sound decisions with the football. From the 2009 to 2010 seasons, Ricky Stanzi increased his touchdowns by 8 and reduced his interceptions by 9 (TD/INT ratio 2009: 17-15 . 2010: 25-6). Stanzi's completion percentage skyrocketed from 56% to 64%, and he improved his QB passer rating by 26 points (131 in '09 to 157).Stanzi eclipsed 220 completions (221 to be exact) and threw for more than 3,000 yards (3,004). 

The improved decision making is evident when you take a look at his game logs from 2009 to 2010. In '09, Stanzi threw 2 or more interceptions (5 versus Indiana in week 9) in 5 games. Moving forward to 2010, Stanzi threw 2 interceptions just one game, being in his final collegiate game versus Missouri in the Insight Bowl. 
Ricky Stanzi after beating Missouri and QB Blaine Gabbert

Weaknesses: With all of the positive attributes listed above, Stanzi still has very average arm strength, lacks zip or velocity, and is inconsistent when throwing intermediate to deep passing routes. Very spotty accuracy and ball placement on deep throws over the middle, this is where he gets into trouble with interceptions. Whenever he gets a late read or progression response, he lacks the throwing velocity to fit the ball into tightly contested windows. Has to be spot on with his timing in order to complete NFL caliber throws.

Doesn't have excellent anticipation and will aim the ball to his receivers at times, thus removing needed velocity and often resulting in INTs. Will lock on to one receiver because of something he sees in his pre snap read and ultimately forces bad throws as a result. Much of his mistakes come from pressing; nothing is open and he tries to complete a pass in tight coverage. The lack of elite arm strength is intensified when the pocket collapses and he tries to force the ball downfield without setting his feet. 

Wasn't asked to make a whole lot of difficult throws and has limited tape of such throws. In its simplest form, the Iowa Hawkeyes offense is tailored to make easy throws for quarterback Ricky Stanzi, and provide running lanes for star running backs Adam Robinson and Jewell Hampton to run behind a stout, senior filled offensive line.


ANALYSIS

Best fit: Overall, Stanzi is an intriguing evaluation for the fact that many of his negative aspects spill over into his positive attributes, as well as positives flowing into negatives. To me, Stanzi is best suited to go to a team with a strong running game, solid offensive line, and athletic receivers that can pick up yards after the catch. He needs to be in an offensive scheme that utilizes slant-stick routes, utilizing a variety of short to intermediate timing routes. In this way Stanzi's film room devotion and work ethic, short to intermediate passing accuracy, and sound footwork can be best utilized.

Jay Gruden and Cincinnati might be interested in the 3rd round should they pass on a QB at picks 4 and 35. The Bengals need a spark of leadership for not only their offense, but their franchise as a whole. The expected release of Terrell Owens, expiring timeline for Chad Ochocinco (soon to be Johnson again), and new young receiving options drafted over the past several years, suggests that the Bengals are turning a new page in their organization. The laughing stock of the league in terms of character issues, the Bengals have more arrests over the last 10 years than any other team in the NFL (might even have more than all other 31 teams combined?). Stanzi could be developed and groomed here as a starter, and with time could have a nice NFL career.

That being said, the best fit would be an NFL team that is already established with a signal caller and strong offense. Stanzi could be given a flyer by a team like New England or Indianapolis, as both teams lack solid depth behind their star QBs Peyton Manning and Tom Brady. 

Stanzi could very well become a solid starter in a few years and go on to enjoy a nice career in the league, and he could just as easily bounce from team to team as a stop gap quarterback and career backup QB if not placed in the correct offensive system. 

Mel Kiper Jr. from ESPN is convinced Cleveland is the best fit. Coach Mike Holmgren has stated that the team will in fact draft a quarterback after the 2nd round




X-Factor: How will teams view his arm strength and velocity? Due to necessity at the position, will a team over draft Ricky Stanzi and expect too much from him too early? The later Stanzi gets drafted, the better in my mind. He will have less pressure, and will be even more motivated to prove others wrong for passing on him.

Where will he be drafted: 3rd to 4th Round

Where should he be drafted: Depending on the team drafting: 3rd if I have an open competition for my starter, Anywhere 4th or later if I have a veteran in place and Stanzi is still available.

NFL Comparison: John David Booty, QB, Houston Texans

2009 Ricky Stanzi highlights "Love it or Leave it" haha, Stanzi is a "real American"


2010-2011 Ricky Stanzi highlights

Saturday, April 9, 2011

Experts Mock Draft: Round 2

Round 2
  1. New England - from Carolina (2-14): Danny Watkins, OL, Baylor
  2. Buffalo (4-12): Nate Solder, OT, Colorado
  3. Cincinnati (4-12): Corey Liuget, DT, Illinois
  4. Denver (4-12): Stephen Paea, DT, Oregon State
  5. Cleveland (5-11): Jabaal Sheard, OLB/DE, Pittsburgh
  6. Arizona (5-11): Kyle Rudolph, TE, Notre Dame
  7. Indianapolis- from Tennessee (6-10): Rodney Hudson, OG/C, Florida State
  8. Dallas (6-10): Marcus Cannon, OT, TCU
  9. Washington (6-10): Christian Ponder, QB, Florida State
  10. Houston (6-10): Bruce Carter, OLB, North Carolina
  11. Seattle- from New Orleans from Minnesota (6-10): Ryan Mallett, QB, Arkansas
  12. Pittsburgh- from Detroit (6-10): Mikell Leshoure, RB, Illinois
  13. San Francisco (6-10): Andy Dalton, QB, TCU
  14. Denver - from Miami (7-9): Aaron Williams, CB, Texas
  15. St. Louis (7-9): Leonard Hankerson, WR, Miami (Fl)
  16. Oakland (8-8): Brandon Harris, CB, Miami (Fl)
  17. Jacksonville (8-8): Rahim Moore, FS, UCLA
  18. San Diego (9-7): Randall Cobb, WR, Kentucky
  19. Tampa Bay (10-6): Ras-I Dowling, CB, Virginia
  20. San Francisco - from NY Giants (10-6): Dontay Moch, OLB, Nevada
  21. Indianapolis* (10-6): Stefen Wisniewski, OG/C, Penn State
  22. Philadelphia* (10-6): Ben Ijalana, OL, Villanova
  23. Kansas City* (10-6): Jon Baldwin, WR, Pittsburgh
  24. New Orleans* (11-5): Marvin Austin, DT, North Carolina
  25. New Orleans- from Seattle* (7-9): Mason Foster, OLB, Washington
  26. Baltimore* (12-4): Orlando Franklin, OT, Miami (Fl)
  27. Atlanta* (13-3): Jerrel Jernigan, WR, Troy
  28. New England* (14-2): Ryan Williams, RB, Virginia Tech
  29. Chicago- from San Diego- from NY Jets* (11-5): Torrey Smith, WR, Maryland
  30. Chicago* (11-5): Clint Boling, OG/T, Georgia
  31. Pittsburgh* (12-4): James Carpenter, OT, Alabama
  32. Green Bay* (10-6): William Rackley, OT, Lehigh



Trades:
Buffalo Bills 1.03 to NE Patriots for 1.17 and 1.28

San Francisco 49ers 1.07 to NY Giants for 1.19 and 2.20

Detroit trades 1.13 to SD Chargers for 1.18, 3rd in 2011, 3rd in 2012

Atlanta trades 1.27, 3.27, and 4.27 to Detroit for 1.18

Indianapolis trades 1.22 to Tennessee for 2.07 and 3.13

New Orleans trades picks 1.24 and 7.23 to Minnesota for 2.11, 4.10, 5.22 and 2012 2nd rounder

Chargers get 2011 1.29, 3.29, 4.30. Bears get 2012 1st, 2011 2:29 (from Jets), 2012 5th 

Detroit trades 2.12 and 3.11 for Pittsburgh 1.31 and 5th rounder

Seattle trades 2012 1st round and 2.25 to New Orleans for 2.11

Friday, April 8, 2011

Experts Mock Draft: Round 1

To find out who is drafting for your favorite NFL team, refer to my list of GM's


Round 1
  1. Carolina (2-14): Cam Newton*, QB, Auburn
  2. Denver (4-12): Robert Quinn, DE, North Carolina
  3. New England from Buffalo (4-12)*: Von Miller, OLB, TAMU
  4. Cincinnati (4-12): Blaine Gabbert, QB, Missouri
  5. Arizona (5-11): Patrick Peterson, CB, LSU
  6. Cleveland (5-11): A.J. Green, WR, Georgia
  7. NY Giants from San Francisco (6-10): Marcell Dareus, DT, Alabama
  8. Tennessee (6-10): Nick Fairley, DT, Auburn
  9. Dallas (6-10): Prince Amukamara, CB, Nebraska
  10. Washington (6-10): Muhammed Wilkerson, DL, Temple
  11. Houston (6-10): Julio Jones, WR, Alabama
  12. Minnesota (6-10): DaQuan Bowers, DE, Clemson
  13. San Diego- from Detroit (6-10): Tyron Smith, OT, USC
  14. St. Louis (7-9): Aldon Smith, DE, Missouri
  15. Miami (7-9): Derek Sherrod, OT, Mississippi State
  16. Jacksonville (8-8): Adrian Clayborn, DE, Iowa
  17. Buffalo Bills- from New England(14-2)*: Cam Jordan, DE, Cal
  18. Atlanta- from Detroit- from San Diego (9-7): Ryan Kerrigan, DE, Purdue
  19. San Francisco from New York Giants (10-6): J.J. Watt, DE, Wisconsin
  20. Tampa Bay (10-6): Anthony Castonzo, OT, Boston College
  21. Kansas City* (10-6): Phil Taylor, NT, Baylor
  22. Tennessee from Indianapolis* (10-6): Colin Kaepernick, QB, Nevada
  23. Philadelphia* (10-6): Mike Pouncey, OG/C, Florida
  24. Minnesota- from New Orleans* (11-5): Jake Locker, QB, Washington
  25. Seattle* (7-9): Gabe Carimi, OT, Wisconsin
  26. Baltimore* (12-4): Jimmy Smith, CB, Colorado
  27. Detroit- from Atlanta* (13-3): Mark Ingram, RB, Alabama
  28. Buffalo Bills- from New England (14-2)*: Brooks Reed, OLB/DE, Arizona
  29. SD Chargers- from Chicago* (11-5): Akeem Ayers, OLB, UCLA
  30. New York Jets* (11-5): Justin Houston, OLB/DE, Georgia
  31. Detroit- from Pittsburgh* (12-4): Martez Wilson, LB, Illinois
  32. Green Bay* (10-6): Cameron Heyward, DE, Ohio State


Trades:
Buffalo Bills 1.03 to NE Patriots for 1.17 and 1.28

San Francisco 49ers 1.07 to NY Giants for 1.19 and 2.20

Detroit trades 1.13 to SD Chargers for 1.18, 3rd in 2011, 3rd in 2012

Atlanta trades 1.27, 3.27, and 4.27 to Detroit for 1.18

Indianapolis trades 1.22 to Tennessee for 2.07 and 3.13

New Orleans trades picks 1.24 and 7.23 to Minnesota for 2.11, 4.10, 5.22 and 2012 2nd rounder

Chargers get 2011 1.29, 3.29, 4.30. Bears get 2012 1st, 2011 2:29 (from Jets), 2012 5th 


Detroit trades 2.12 and 3.11 for Pittsburgh 1.31 and 5th rounder












  • Oakland; New England: Richard Seymour 
  • Thursday, April 7, 2011

    Upcoming 2011 NFL Mock Draft

    This Saturday, April 9th at 10 a.m. The 3-4 will be hosting a variety of NFL Draft analysts to participate in a 3 round mock draft. Here are the drafters for each NFL team and their respective sites (or Twitter accounts)

    1. Carolina Panthers- Chad Reuter (Input from Rob Rang of CBS)
    2. Denver Broncos- Draft Zoo
    3. Buffalo Bills- Eric Samulski
    4. Cincinnati Bengals- Joe Goodberry
    5. Arizona Cardinals- NFL Draft Monsters
    6. Cleveland Browns- Aaron Aloysius
    7. San Francisco 49ers- Sean Silveira
    8. Tennessee Titans- Walker Rhodes
    9. Dallas Cowboys- LaSportsDude
    10. Washington Redskins- Nick Stilwell
    11. Houston Texans- Houston Diehards
    12. Minnesota Vikings- Gil Alcaraz IV
    13. Detroit Lions- Michael Schottey
    14. St. Louis Rams- Tyson Langland
    15. Miami Dolphins- Eric Galko
    16. Jacksonville Jaguars- Scot Acocks
    17. Oakland Raiders- Wes Bunting
    18. San Diego Chargers- Evan Silva
    19. New York Giants- Mike Hroncich
    20. Tampa Bay Bucs- Mark "Shark"
    21. Kansas City Chiefs- Jinx Allessio
    22. Indianapolis Colts- Jared Counterman
    23. Philadelphia Eagles- @IronLungRyan
    24. New Orleans Saints- Jason Bernos
    25. Seattle Seahawks- Chad Davis
    26. Baltimore Ravens- Rob Engle
    27. Atlanta Falcons- @mFalcons5
    28. New England Patriots- OUR very own, Keith McGonigle
    29. New York Jets- Hunter Buckalew
    30. Chicago Bears- Michael Harman
    31. Pittsburgh Steelers- Kevin Cornaire
    32. Green Bay Packers- Chad Reuter

    Sunday, April 3, 2011

    Andy Dalton Scouting Report

    Andy Dalton, QB, TCU, 6'2 215 lbs


    SKILLS

    Strengths: The consummate winner, Andy Dalton set a TCU record with 42 career victories as opposed to only 7 losses. 6 of those 7 losses were by 7 points or less, an indication of how the Horned Frogs were almost always in a position to win just about EVERY game Andy Dalton quarterbacked from 2007-2010. A four year starter after being redshirted his true freshman season, Dalton improved his completion percentage, yards per attempt, TD/INT ratio, passer rating, and lowered his sack total in each consecutive year as the chart below shows…




    Year
    Completion Percentage
    Yards per Attempt
    TD/INT Ratio
    QB Passer Rating
    Sack Total
    2007
    59%
    6.63
    0.9 (10-11)
    118.48
    16
    2008
    59%
    7.3
    2.2 (11-5)
    129.19
    14
    2009
    61%
    8.53
    2.9 (23-8)
    151.83
    12
    2010
    66%
    9.04
    4.5 (27-6)
    166.48
    8

    Not only did he just win games though, Dalton also led TCU to a bowl game in every season he started as QB (3-1 record in those games). 

    Running for a score in TCU's Rose Bowl win vs Wisconsin
    Andy Dalton has good size for an NFL starting quarterback (6'2 215 lbs) and despite being criticized for his lack of physical attributes, Dalton showed mobility and toughness throughout his career. He carried the football more than 400 times and lost zero fumbles. Has ability to make people miss moving from within the pocket as well as out in space, while still maintaining control of the ball. 

    He has a nice quick release, does a great job of squaring his shoulder to the target and getting the ball out. This can be seen in TCU's quick passing game which is full of screens, bubble routes, and 3 step passing game routes. Dalton's extraordinary anticipation of throwing windows makes him a very accurate passer. His anticipation, high football IQ, and timing with receivers more than makes up for his lack of elite arm strength and velocity. 

    In his March pro day, Dalton was said to have been impeccably accurate with the football; all 50 passes were catchable and his velocity impressed a number of the scouts in attendance. 46 representatives from 26 separate NFL clubs were present for the TCU pro-day.

    Devoted work ethic, high character kid, and fearless leader, Andy Dalton has the mental makeup that any team would love to have. He wins ball games, motivates his teammates, throws the football accurately, and cuts down on turnovers.

    Very similar to Colt Mccoy in that Andy has a strong will and high character; skill set similarities include accuracy, anticipation, and mobility.


    Weaknesses: Albeit Dalton has an excellent mental make-up and other important quarterback qualities, this QB lacks elite arm strength and was rarely called upon to throw deep passes outside the numbers and downfield. I will say he displayed nice touch on his deep balls, I do not see the ability to really drive routes 25-30 yards downfield. This combined with his relatively average velocity, makes me believe his draft placement is limited to a west coast offensive scheme.

    This next weakness is more of a quirk than anything, but is hardly recognized in scouting community. At times, Dalton will show a similar delivery to Colin Kaepernick. Kaepernick, whom I see as a late 1st round talent, has been largely criticized for his awkward and unconventional delivery that I believe stems from his high school pitching days. Kaepernick will pronate his non-throwing left arm while bringing the ball behind his head, creating a strange illusion to film watchers. In a similar fashion, Dalton will do this very thing. Given he doesn't consistently make this mechanical error, Dalton needs to clean up this part of his throwing motion.

    Another problem I find is his upright throwing stance lacking strong knee bend and active feet. As I have noted earlier, Dalton has the ability to get out and run, however Dalton is just beginning to show a comfort level necessary within the passing pocket. Dalton has to improve on being more active with his feet in feeling pressure,  sliding to avoid sacks, and get more stride into his throws. That being said, I have to counter this by stating that Andy does a good job with his feet in relation to the base of his throws in that he doesn't have an issue with over striding. 

    Finally, the most talked over weakness of all quarterbacks in this draft class, the spread option system. Andy Dalton at TCU ran a spread-run option system that utilized a gun-option effectively, while spitting the ball out to slot receivers in a short, consistent 3 step timing manner. The occasional deep pass was utilized efficiently, and a strong running attack was prevalent. I will say that there are a number of plays evidencing Dalton's ability to go through a progression, however in most of his throws Dalton would catch the snap, simply rock back, and throw a pre-determined read. The pre-snap part of Dalton's game is a strong suit on one hand, nonetheless a majority of the throws Dalton made were fairly simple and easy completions. The biggest thing going forward is getting Dalton comfortable dropping back from center, making reads in that drop, and learning how to get adequate knee bend and foot-action (no pun intended) in order to drive the football downfield. 

    ANALYSIS

    Best fit: First off the team must be a West coast system. That knocks off quite a few teams, but most teams implementing a WCO in the league today are in need of a QB. Those teams include San Francisco, Minnesota, Seattle, and Washington. 

    While all of the previously mentioned franchises likely have a strong interest, as will many other teams looking for serviceable backups, I see the Minnesota Vikings as being the best fit for Andy Dalton schematically and in accordance with the player personnel.

    In the best season of Brett Favre's career (statistically), Favre was most effective in throwing the short dump-off or screen routes, completing more passes (126) in attempts from 1-10 yards than any other area on the field. From the film I've seen, Dalton as afore mentioned, was equally effective in the short passing game at TCU. In that 2009 season, the Vikings were a stone's throw from making the NFL's Super Bowl; the reason for such a dramatic dropout in 2010 obviously stems from the lethargic play of Brett Favre. After throwing for 14 TDs and zero picks in attempts 11-20 yards in 2009, Favre threw 4 TDs to 8 interceptions in the same attempt range. Moreover, Favre's TD/INT ratio in 2009 for attempts 1-10 yards was 10/2, while in 2010 the ratio fell to a lousy 5/4.

    By bringing in Dalton, the Vikings can actually rebuild the state of the franchise from within. They can wait until round 2, trade down right in front of Seattle, and get Dalton for a much lower price than signing another veteran quarterback or trading for Kevin Kolb once a CBA is met. Dalton has less of the major concerns that the top QBs of this class have, and would be a much safer pick in rounds 2 or 3 depending on the vibe around the league. Dalton teamed with Percy Harvin in the quick hitting passing attack, and Adrian Peterson pounding the running game could bring some life back to a dying Minnesota Vikings offense. In round 1 the Vikings can address glaring needs on defense, draft Dalton on day 2, and possibly draft Dalton's go to man Jeremy Kerley late on day 3. 

    X-Factor: Can Dalton overcome the "weak arm" and "spread system quarterback" labels placed upon him? How will these West Coast offense teams address their needs at the quarterback? In my mind, there's no time to wait as long as there's no CBA. If teams draft as differently as I think they will, then Dalton could go higher than expected. 

    Where will he be drafted: In the middle portion of the 2nd Round

    Where should he be drafted: 3rd Round- There's so much depth across the board on the defensive side, talent-wise, to pass up. Dalton will be drafted much earlier than expected by a West Coast Offense desperate for immediate quarterback help.

    NFL Comparison: Colt Mccoy, QB, Cleveland Browns

    Andy Dalton vs. San Diego State


    Andy Dalton highlight tape